MA WEE TIN O’ SHORTBREID
Scotland as advertised
Ma Wee Tin o’ Shortbreid is a work in progress about tourism, national identity and the packaging of Scotland’s Highlands and Islands. The title comes from those old shortbread tins every Scottish family used for their photographs - the ones with a romantic Scotland on the lid: a castle, a Highland coo and permanent sunshine. Made on repeated camper van trips, it follows the visitors who come for that picture and the empty roads, and end up waiting for everyone else to shift out the frame. The pictures are about the gap between Scotland as advertised and the place people find.
MA WEE TIN O’ SHORTBREID
Scotland as advertised
Growing up in Scotland, most families kept their photographs in an old shortbread tin. Mine did too. The lid always showed a castle beside a loch, a stag or a Highland coo, and plenty of tartan. Always sunny. Ma Wee Tin o’ Shortbreid is Scots for ‘my little tin of shortbread’. The title started as a warning to myself: don’t make the Highlands look like a tin of shortbread. Then, at Eilean Donan Castle, about as biscuit-tin as it gets, I photographed a Chinese tourist under a wee umbrella, remaking the view for her own photograph. The warning became the title.
The Scotland on the lid promises wilderness, history, escape and a warm welcome. The real one arrives with a car park, a midgie forecast and a queue. The landscape looks conveniently empty. Some of that emptiness was made. Highland regiments went off to fight the empire’s wars while the glens were cleared for sheep and sporting estates. The view people come for was once somebody’s home.
Visitors turn up looking for a Scotland they’ve already seen on screens. They come for wilderness and find a coach park and a long wait for somebody to shift out the frame. At the famous spots I kept noticing how many of the visitors were Chinese and Indian, from countries Britain once ruled, traded with or fought. They were photographing the familiar symbols of old Scotland. This time Scotland was the attraction and they were the ones behind the camera.
Even the weather is for sale. In what felt like London’s hottest summer ever, Londoners drove north for cool air and rain. A week of horizontal rain soon tests the sales pitch.
I’m making the project from my camper van on repeated trips across the Highlands and Islands - 60 days so far. I’ve been back to Skye five times, crossed to many of the islands and driven the NC500 both ways. It grew out of Weather Permitting, my pictures of Scotland’s ski centres, and kept going.
Camper van life has its own pitch: freedom, independence, a new view every morning. In practice it depends on ferry bookings, fresh water, waste points and somewhere you’re allowed to stop. Freedom, it turns out, needs a booking reference.
Travelling this way, I’m part of what I’m photographing, on the same roads, ferries and overnight stops as everyone else. The open road can still end at a full lay-by or a No Motorhomes sign. Passing places become car parks. Viewpoints become campsites.
An empty road makes a fine advert. Everyone driving down it makes a different picture.
The NC500 has been a named tourist route for just over a decade, selling 516 miles of empty road. It worked. What it will look like in another ten or twenty years is anyone’s guess. Part of making these photographs is simply recording this moment before we find out.
The pictures are about the gap between Scotland as advertised and the place people actually find. I set out not to photograph the shortbread tin. I kept finding people trying to climb inside it. And inside, there were always more pictures.